What is Provisional Liquidation?
During the period between when an application for a winding up order is made and the hearing of that application (or any appeal against a winding up order), the Court may appoint a registered liquidator provisionally to the company to preserve the status quo of the company until the application for a winding up order has been determined by the Court. The power of the Court to appoint a provisional liquidator is found in section 472(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act). While the appointment of a provisional liquidator is not common, and the cases in which the Court may appoint a provisional liquidator are not closed, where there is a genuine concern about harm being occasioned by the continued operation of a company by its officers, the appointment of a provisional liquidator may be an important tool to deploy in the wind-up process.
Although there are similarities in the role of a liquidator and a provisional liquidator, there are key differences. For instance, the role of a provisional liquidator, which is explained further below, is to preserve the status quo of the company pending the determination of the application to wind up the company. On the other hand, the role of a liquidator is to realise and distribute the company’s assets to its creditors and, if there is a surplus, then to its shareholders. Further, while provisional liquidators often have an investigative function, that investigative function is invariably deployed to assist the Court in determining the application to wind-up a company, rather than to bring about further returns to creditors or shareholders, which is the role of a liquidator.
The Powers, Roles and Responsibilities of Provisional Liquidators
While provisional liquidators have various responsibilities in the proper discharge of their functions, their primary objective is to maintain the status quo, preserve the company’s property and, if the company is operating a business, to continue carrying on that business. Provisional liquidators are also often required to report to the Court about the progress of their control of the company, and the outcome of any investigations into the affairs of the company. As part of that process, the Court may order the provisional liquidator to opine about various issues, including whether the company has been managed properly, whether the provisional liquidator considers the company is insolvent or any other matter which might be relevant to the Court’s determination of the application to wind up the company.
In the exercise of their functions, provisional liquidators have vast statutory powers pursuant to sections 472(3) and 472(4) of the Act, which confers upon provisional liquidators the same powers that a liquidator of the company would have under sections 477(2) (except section 477(2)(m)) and 477(3) of the Act. Those powers include to:
1. bring or defend legal proceedings in the name of and on behalf of the company;
2. carry on the company's business;
3. appoint a solicitor;
4. sell or otherwise dispose of the company's property. While the sale of property otherwise than in the normal course of a business will not ordinarily be necessary, maintenance of the status quo may require a prompt sale of assets. However, before a provisional liquidator sells any asset of significant value, they should (acting prudently) seek an order of the Court permitting them to do so under s 90-15 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations). While there is no obligation on them to seek such an order, in doing so, the provisional liquidator will have a legitimate defence to a claim that the sale should not have taken place;
5. compromise the company's claims;
6. do all acts and execute in the name and on behalf of the company all documents;
7. prove in the bankruptcy of a debtor of the company;
8. obtain credit, whether on the security of the property of the company or otherwise;
9. appoint an agent to do any business that the provisional liquidator is unable to do or that it is unreasonable to expect the provisional liquidator to do; and
10. inspect the books and records of the company.
The Court also has a broad power to confer upon provisional liquidators such powers that it specifies in the order appointing the provisional liquidator in the furtherance of their statutory function and to assist the Court in its determination of the application to wind-up the company. Such orders include orders requiring the provisional liquidator to conduct an investigation into the company and its officers, and to report to the Court about those investigations.
Once a provisional liquidator has been appointed, they are officers of the Court and, accordingly, the Court can make orders in its inherent jurisdiction to assist the provisional liquidator perform his or her statutory function: Re PR Clark Holdings Pty Ltd (1977) 2 ACLR 416, 418–9. The Court may also make orders in its inherent jurisdiction controlling the exercise of the provisional liquidator’s powers, as conferred by the Court.
When May Provisional Liquidators be Appointed?
As mentioned above, the cases in which the Court may appoint a provisional liquidator are not closed. However, the most common type of case where the Court is asked to appoint a provisional liquidator is a case where, having applied to the Court for an order winding up a company, the applicant has a bona fide concern that the company’s property or affairs are being mismanaged and that the continued operation of the company by its officers will cause significant (potentially irreparable) harm to creditors, employees, shareholders and other stakeholders. While corporate mismanagement and significant harm are not necessary preconditions to the Court appointing a provisional liquidator, those factors will go a long way to satisfying the Court that a provisional liquidator should be appointed to preserve the status quo and the assets of the company, pending the Court’s determination of the application to wind up the company.
Those factors aside, the relevant principles to which the Court will have regard in determining whether to appoint a provisional liquidator were set out by Tamberlin J in Australian Securities Commission v Solomon, Transphere (Sth Pacific) Pty Ltd, Eddie Solomon Emporium Pty Ltd (1996) 19 ACSR 73. At 80, his Honour listed the following principles:
(a) The court should only appoint a provisional liquidator where it is satisfied that there is a valid and duly authorised winding up application and that there is a reasonable prospect that a winding up order will be made: see Debelle J in Re J N Taylor Holdings Ltd; Zempilas v J N Taylor Holdings Ltd (1991) 3 ACSR 516; 9 ACLC 1 at 12-3.
(b) The fact that the assets of the corporation may be at risk is a relevant consideration.
(c) The provisional liquidator's primary duty is to preserve the status quo to ensure the least possible harm to all concerned and to enable the court to decide, after a further examination, whether the company should be wound up: Re Carapark Industries Pty Ltd (in liq) (1966) 9 FLR 297; 86 WN (Pt 1) (NSW) 165 at 171.
(d) The court should consider the degree of urgency, the need established by the applicant creditor and the balance of convenience: Re Club Mediterranean Pty Ltd (1975) 11 SASR 481 at 484 per Bright J. The power is a broad one and circumstances will vary greatly. Commercial affairs are infinitely complex and various and it is inappropriate to limit the power by restricting its exercise to fixed categories or classes of circumstances or fact.
(e) It may be appropriate to appoint a provisional liquidator in the public interest where there is a need for an independent examination of the state of accounts of the corporation by someone other than the directors: Tickle v Crest Insurance Co of Australia Ltd (1984) 2 ACLC 493.
(f) Where the affairs of the company have been carried on casually and without due regard to legal requirements so as to leave the court with no confidence that the company's affairs would be properly conducted with due regard for the interests of shareholders, it may be appropriate to appoint a provisional liquidator: see Montgomery Windsor (NSW) Pty Ltd v Ilopa Pty Ltd (1984) 2 ACLC 224.
Further principles relevant to an application to appoint provisional liquidators were summarised by Master Lee QC in Re McLennan Holdings Pty Ltd (1983) 7 ACLR 732 as follows (at 737-8):
(1) A provisional liquidator is not automatically appointed by the court for the mere asking by the company even when the company presents its own petition.
(2) A provisional liquidator may only be appointed after presentation of a duly authorized petition which must disclose a good ground for winding up: s 372(2): Re Clearwater Pty Ltd, supra.
(3) There must be sufficient proof that the presentation of the petition was duly authorized and that the requirements of s 248 of the Code have been duly complied with: Smith v The Duke of Manchester, supra; Re Sanders Ltd, supra; Re Clearwater Pty Ltd, supra; McPherson, Law of Company Liquidation, 2nd ed, p 132 and cases cited.
(4) Whilst the ultimate fate of the petition must be left to the court finally hearing the matter, a provisional liquidator will not usually be appointed unless it appears in the material that a winding up order is likely: Re Railway Finance Company (Ltd) (1866) 35 Beav 472 ; 55 ER 979 at 980; Re Mercantile Bank of Australia [1892] 2 Ch 204 at 210; Clearwater Pty Ltd, supra McPherson, Law of Company Liquidation, 2nd ed, p 84. This presupposes that there should be adequate evidence adduced on an application for appointment of a provisional liquidator to show that a winding up is, in the absence of material to the contrary, likely.
(5) A company seeking the appointment of a provisional liquidator after presentation of its own petition must at least show that the application is for a bona fide purpose. This may be established by showing by affidavit some sufficient ground for the appointment as expressly required by r 51(1), which implies that a sufficient ground must be shown which is not necessarily the same as the ground relied upon for a winding up order, such a ground being necessary to found the petition itself. Accordingly, a mere resolution that a company be wound up is not without more a sufficient ground for the appointment of a provisional liquidator: cf Re Hammersmith Town Hall Company, supra, where the ground relied upon was explicitly proved by affidavit.
(6) The power to appoint a provisional liquidator is in no way limited: Pitt v Bachmann & Anor, supra, and the circumstances (which may constitute sufficient ground) under which a provisional liquidator may be appointed are infinite: Re Club Mediterranean Pty Ltd 1975 11 SASR 481, 484 McPherson, Law of Company Liquidation, 2nd ed, p 84; Re Union Accident Insurance Company Ltd, supra, (public interest). There is no reason why the public interest should not operate in favour of or against the making of an appointment in particular circumstances; see also in Re Johannesburg Land & Gold Trust Co, supra.
(7) Whilst mere evidence of insolvency alone is usually insufficient to justify the appointment of a provisional liquidator at the instance of a creditor: Re Hammersmith Town Hall Company, supra; Re Hall & Plummer (Merchants) Ltd (1956) NZLR 979 at 780, McPherson, Law of Company Liquidation, 2nd ed, p 83, such evidence in the case of an application by a company may be sufficient to show that the application is bona fide and may be capable of constituting a “sufficient ground” within the meaning of r 51(1) in the particular circumstances of the case: cf Re Cilfoden Building Soc, supra, Emmerson's case, supra, and Australian Company Law (Paterson and Ednie), 2nd ed, vol 3, para 231A/7, p 2596.2.
(8) A provisional liquidator will usually not be appointed upon application by a company after presentation of its own petition based only upon the ground that the company has resolved that it be wound up if the only demonstrated purpose is to defeat or delay a proceeding in a court, or if there is no useful purpose in appointing a provisional liquidator; cf s 382(2), r51(2), having regard to the fact that an appointment operates only until the hearing and determination of the petition to wind up or further earlier order.
(9) If sufficient grounds are shown the court may in its discretion appoint a provisional liquidator not withstanding that a consequence is that a subsisting action is effectively stayed pending the obtaining of leave to proceed by a party to that action as contemplated by s 371(2). The rights of third parties affected in such circumstances may be protected by an application to the court: Wallace and Young, Australian Company Law p 663; Dry Docks Corporation, supra, at 314 per Fry LJ.
Who Can Apply to Appoint a Provisional Liquidator?
The Act does not set out the persons who may apply for the appointment of a provisional liquidator. That having been said, an applicant for the appointment of a provisional liquidator must have standing to seek the appointment. Persons who have standing include:
1. the company itself;
2. a creditor of a company, although a creditor with an undetermined claim for unliquidated damages is not entitled to seek the appointment of a provisional liquidator (Nationwide Produce Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) (2002) 20 ACLC 309, [7]), nor is a person who is a beneficiary under a trust of which the company is the trustee, unless that person is also a creditor of the company (Phelan v Ambridge Corp Pty Ltd (2005) 55 ACSR 136, [22] – [32]);
3. any contributory; or
4. the Australian Securities and Investments Commission.
Key Considerations in Deciding Whether to Seek the Appointment of Provisional Liquidators
There are many commercial, legal and practical considerations in deciding whether to seek the appointment of provisional liquidators. They include:
1. Where a provisional liquidator has been appointed, no proceeding against the company or in relation to the company’s property may be commenced or continued without the leave of the Court under section 471B of the Act. So, if you are a creditor of a company which is subject to a winding up application, and you have separate proceedings on foot, you should be mindful of the fact that if a provisional liquidator is appointed, those proceedings will be stayed unless you obtain leave of the Court to continue prosecuting the proceeding.
2. Although the provisional liquidator is likely to be appointed as the liquidator upon the Court making a winding up order because they are likely to have acquired information during their appointment as provisional liquidator which will be useful in the liquidation and will avoid duplication of work, the Court is not required to appoint the provisional liquidator as the liquidator (see, eg, Attalex Pty Ltd v Brian Cassidy Electrical Industries Pty Ltd (1984) 9 ACLR 144).
3. The Court may require the applicant to give an undertaking as to damages (see, eg, Supreme Court (Corporations) Rules 1999 (NSW), r 6.1(4)). If the applicant’s undertaking is worthless or inadequate then, without more (for instance, an undertaking or security proffered by a third party), the Court may refuse to appoint a provisional liquidator.
4. A provisional liquidator has the benefit of an equitable lien over the company’s property for any unpaid remuneration or expenses, which survives the termination of their appointment (see Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Samalot Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2) (1986) 10 ACLR 748, 751).
5. The Court is unlikely to appoint a provisional liquidator if there are other, less drastic, measures to preserve the status quo (Zempilas v JN Taylor Holdings Ltd (No2) (1990) 3 ACSR 518, 522).
How We Can Help
We have vast experience acting for administrators, liquidators, receivers and managers, controllers, directors, other company officers and employees, creditors and other parties interested in the administration process. With that vast experience, we can provide comprehensive and tailored advice and legal representation about whether you should seek the appointment of provisional liquidators or acting for provisional liquidators.
If you require advice or legal representation in connection with any part of the appointment of provisional liquidators, please do not hesitate to contact our office.
Disclaimer
The above is general commentary only and is not legal advice. It is also not an exhaustive statement of the law, nor is it specific to your circumstances. If you are considering seeking orders for the appointment of provisional liquidators or area provisional liquidator, you should seek proper and tailored legal advice. Our team of lawyers is well equipped to assist you in this regard.
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)

.png)
.png)
.png)

.png)
.png)





.webp)



.webp)
%20(1).webp)
.webp)
.webp)





.webp)
.jpeg)